- Nobody ever walked away from a gun fight saying, “All that extra ammo was worthless, and I wish I wasn’t carrying it.”
- The only times when you can have too much ammo are when you are on fire or you are drowning.
- You should always have extra ammo and magazines because you never know when you will get the urge to go to the range and get in some practice.
The Debate
All quips aside, there is actually a debate in the industry about the amount of ammo that you carry and whether you should have an extra magazine. I find this very interesting for a few reasons, which I hope I can articulate well enough to make you confused.
Starring in this discussion are two people that I respect, immensely. There are others that weigh in on one side of the other, but these two do a great job of explaining their positions.
In one corner, we have John Correia of Active Self Protection. He proposes not carrying extra ammo or an extra magazine.
In the other corner, we have Massad Ayoob who needs no introduction. He proposes going the extra step and being prepared by carrying an extra magazine with extra ammo.
I have my opinion, and my opinion matters more to me than John’s or Massad’s. Your opinion may or may not change after reading this, but please, just make sure you at least carry. What you do beyond that is a personal decision.
John Correia
I will summarize John’s stance, here, and I am paraphrasing:
- Stats say that while we may be required to defend ourselves from violent crime over our lives, the stats say that it is almost zero chance you will need to reload or you will be able to reload before the gunfight is over.
- Our mission is to disengage from the threat, not to apprehend the criminal.
- It is better to carry other tools that you will need more often like a light, a less lethal, and a medical kit.
- Carrying an extra magazine is emotionally driven, not statistically driven.
Please watch John’s videos on this subject. He is very articulate and very comfortable with his view. It is important to note that John has analyzed 10’s of thousands of videos of private citizen gunfights.
John does a great job of presenting the stats. Please watch his videos for those stats. I am not going to regurgitate them for you.
Massad Ayoob
If you don’t know this name, then you haven’t been doing a good job of keeping up on the self-defense industry.
Massad’s point of view is pretty clear, and he isn’t concerned with statistics. His view is easily summarized (again, I am paraphrasing):
- The gun is an emergency response tool. It must function when it is needed.
- The gun is a temporary tool unless you can reload it.
- If you need your gun, you may need every round available.
- You should prepare for the worst and hope for the best.
- Three are three very clear reasons why you should have an extra magazine:
- Shooting might go high volume. It is possible that you will be on the extreme end of the statistical curve and you will be in an extended gunfight. You don’t want to run out of ammo.
- Magazines fail. You should have another or you may be on the short end of the gunfight if you can’t continue in the event of a magazine failure.
- You might have to struggle to retain your gun from somebody trying to take it from you. In that struggle, your magazine can be ejected, or it could be knocked out of battery during the struggle.
My Opinion
Like I stated, previously, my opinion matters more to me than John’s or Massad’s. I came my opinion over many long periods of thought. Your opinion should matter more to you than mine, but my opinion is the right one.
John kind of tries to shame people into his view by saying that those that carry an extra magazine do it out of emotion and comfort. I don’t ever accept that kind of pressure. However, stats say you won’t ever need an extra magazine.
While many people may say that carrying a magazine is starting down the slippery slope, I am absolutely fine with deciding where my line is at, and again, I will not be shamed into making a decision that doesn’t fit with my perspective on the value of innocent life.
However, if you do need an extra magazine, and you don’t have one, I hope you are right with your God.
I, like Massad, don’t care about the stats. It isn’t about the small odds, it is about the stakes. What is at stake is my life and the lives of my loved ones. I will take the extra step of carrying an extra magazine when I consider what can be lost.
The decision to carry an extra magazine is based upon risk (odds), but it is also based upon the individual’s risk appetite. My risk appetite is extremely conservative, and it involves innocent lives which have great value.
Will I ever need an extra mag? It is highly unlikely. Will I ever even need my carry gun? Well, so far, I have only needed it once while away from home, and the draw was all it took to eliminate the threat. The only time I had to use it in self defense (as a private citizen) was in my home where extra mags are easily accessible and don’t need to be carried on my body.
How important is your life and the lives of your loved ones? Can I compare the importance of those lives to a stat? Yeah… No. No, I can’t make life decisions based on a stat. Can you?